
TL;DR
Proxmox VE is an option for virtualising traditional workloads. OpenStack provides infrastructure as cloud services with APIs, projects and resource quotas. Kubernetes manages containerised applications. The right choice depends on application requirements, how teams obtain resources and who runs the platform. Several platforms can form part of the same architecture.
Three names, different responsibilities
When businesses modernise infrastructure, a familiar question appears: Proxmox, OpenStack or Kubernetes?
The question becomes more useful when we separate two decisions: How are compute, networking and storage provided? And how are applications deployed and operated on top?
Proxmox and OpenStack can provide infrastructure for virtual machines. Kubernetes runs containerised workloads on provisioned machines, including VMs in these environments. A suitable target architecture can therefore include both a virtualisation layer and Kubernetes.
Proxmox: When the VM fits the application
Proxmox VE integrates KVM for virtual machines and LXC for Linux containers. For IT decision-makers, the practical question is whether established applications can retain a proven operating model.
An example is business software whose vendor requires a particular operating system environment. For applications that rarely change, containerisation effort may also outweigh the expected benefit. A VM can remain an appropriate foundation.
Proxmox also provides a REST API. Automation is therefore not exclusive to OpenStack. The relevant distinction is the workflow you need and how it fits your organisation.
Before migrating, verify vendor support, licensing conditions, performance requirements and recovery procedures in the target environment. A successful installation does not replace this assessment.
OpenStack: When infrastructure becomes a service teams can request
OpenStack is worth assessing when teams need to obtain infrastructure through defined cloud interfaces. Its Nova compute service provisions instances; other services handle areas such as identity, images and networking. Resource quotas limit consumption per project.
This can suit organisations where several teams repeatedly need their own environments and want to integrate provisioning into automated processes. The decision also concerns the operating model: Who can create resources? Which standards apply? How is capacity allocated and returned?
These benefits come with the responsibility of operating multiple cooperating services. Establish who handles updates, troubleshooting and capacity planning. An API alone does not justify that work.
Kubernetes: When the application lifecycle takes centre stage
Kubernetes manages containerised workloads against a declared desired state. It provides mechanisms for rollouts, service discovery and distributing replicas.
This can suit applications that change frequently and whose components need independent deployment. The application must support that operating model; a container image alone does not demonstrate readiness.
Ask where persistent data lives, how configuration and secrets are supplied, what happens when an instance is replaced and whether the application can actually use additional replicas.
Databases can also run on Kubernetes. Storage, data replication, backups and recovery still require application-specific planning. A StatefulSet does not remove that responsibility.
A guide to common requirements
These mappings are starting points for assessment, rather than technical restrictions:
| Requirement | Possible starting point | Key assessment |
|---|---|---|
| Move established business software with limited changes | VM on Proxmox or OpenStack | Vendor support, migration and recovery |
| Teams regularly need infrastructure through cloud APIs | OpenStack | Provisioning workflows, quotas and operational ownership |
| Containerised services receive frequent, independent updates | Kubernetes | Application architecture and team capabilities |
| Traditional applications coexist with new containerised services | VM platform combined with Kubernetes | Interfaces, data flows and ownership |
| A small, stable application has straightforward provisioning needs | Assess the existing VM model first | Does another platform justify its operating effort? |
Team responsibilities are part of the architecture
Base the platform decision on a concrete application profile. Five questions help:
- Which environments does the software vendor support?
- How frequently do the application and its resource needs change?
- Which data must survive, and how quickly must service recover?
- Which tasks should teams perform themselves?
- Who owns the platform, guest operating system and application in daily operations?
Alongside resources and support, assess training, migration, parallel operation and ongoing maintenance. Any platform that introduces work needs a clear corresponding benefit.
Modernisation can take a different path for each workload
One possible approach is to retain existing business software on a VM and run new services on Kubernetes. Add OpenStack where its cloud provisioning model is required.
Test whether this combination makes sense using a representative pilot. Include a normal update, a failure scenario and a recovery exercise. These show whether the architecture works in everyday operations.
ayedo supports target environment selection from assessment and architecture through migration to the agreed platform operations. We match Proxmox, OpenStack and Kubernetes to the requirements of your applications.
Talk to us about the next cloud step for your infrastructure.
Read more: Cloud migration without a big bang.
Technical background: Proxmox VE, OpenStack Nova, OpenStack resource quotas, Kubernetes and StatefulSets.